Best Bottle for Messy Eater: Our Top 4 Picks!

If you are searching for a bottle to feed a messy eater, you are in the right place. I have included the list along with an explanation of why you should buy them. So, when it comes to the best bottle for a messy eater, consider the following options

  • Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Bottle if you are looking for the best anti-colic bottle
  • Tommee Tippee Closer to Natural Bodies Bottle if your priority is having the best bottle for slow flow
  • Comotomo Silicone Baby Bottle if you want to have the easiest bottle to clean
  • Philips Avent Anti-Colic Baby Bottles if the aim is to get the best bottle for a comfortable mealtime

Understandably feeding a messy eater can be challenging. That’s why I have also laid out a detailed buying guide for your convenience. You can reduce the mess and make feeding time easier with our best bottle for a messy eater guide.

Top Bottles for Messy Eater

The table below lays out some of the bottles that are the best to feed a messy eater properly. 

BottleBottle Nipple TypeUnique FeaturePrice
Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic BottleNarrow BottleBest Anti-Colic BottleCheck Price
Tommee Tippee Closer to Natural Bodies BottleSuper Sensitive and Optimum VentingBest Bottle for Slow FlowCheck Price
Comotomo Silicone Baby BottleVentedEasiest Bottle to CleanCheck Price
Philips Avent Anti-Colic Baby BottlesVentedBest Bottle to Reduce DiscomfortCheck Price

From the table, you can observe that Dr.Brown’s Natural Flow is a good choice for an anti-colic bottle. There are two bottles with vented-type bottle nipples and Tommee Tippee has two types of bottle nipples. To get a detailed idea about the price, click the ‘Check Price Button’. 

Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Bottle:

Best Anti-Colic Bottle:


  • Material: Polypropylene or Glass
  • Available Sizes: Plastic [2 oz, 4 oz, 8 oz] and Glass [5 oz, 9 oz] 


  • Helps reduce gas and colic
  • Preserves the nutrients
  • Popular parent pick
  • Comes with a slow-flow nipple


  • Lots of parts to clean

Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic bottle is the top choice of parents seeking a solution to colic and gas. These bottles are designed with a patented venting system that closely imitates breastfeeding, effectively minimizing air bubbles and common feeding issues such as burping, gas, and spit-up. The venting system is clinically proven to reduce colic, providing parents with peace of mind. 

The bottles are available in two material options: polypropylene and glass. You will get a size range from 2 to 9 oz if you get a plastic or glass bottle. Both options offer the same benefits, so parents can choose according to their preferences. 

One of the standout features of Dr.Brown’s Natural Flow bottle is the breast-like nipple. This design encourages a proper latch and ensures a consistent flow of milk. It allows the babies to feed at their own pace. The bottles come with a Level 1 slow-flow nipple, making them suitable for newborns. 

Dr.Brown’s bottles are widely chosen by parents for their functionality and popularity. Due to their vacuum-free feeding system, they preserve the essential nutrients in milk and formula. This feature ensures that babies receive the necessary nourishment without compromise. 

While Dr. Brown’s bottles offer significant benefits, it is important to consider a few factors. The highly effective venting system, although beneficial, consists of multiple parts and tiny crevices that require thorough cleaning. This aspect can be time-consuming for some parents. Compared to Comotomo Silicone Baby bottles this is a disadvantage. 

Parents seeking a way to reduce feeding issues will find Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic bottle a reliable option. With its innovative design, go for Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow anti-colic bottle for a less messy meal experience. 

Tommee Tippee Closer to Natural Bodies Bottle:

Best Bottle for Slow Flow:


  • Material: Polypropylene
  • Available Sizes: 5 oz, 9 oz


  • Slow flow nipple
  • Provides a good natural latch and comfortable grasp for both the baby and the parent
  • Easy to clean


  • Not safe for dishwasher
  • Potential leakage
  • Liquid can get trapped’

Tommee Tippee bottles offer a range of benefits to enhance the feeding experience for both babies and parents. Preemies, newborns, and younger babies will find these bottles comfortable and natural to feed from. 

The slow-flow nipple of Tommee Tippee bottles is specifically designed for preemies and newborns. This allows them to pace their sucking and swallowing while ensuring they can breathe comfortably during feedings.

Mimicking the shape and movement of a breast, the soft silicone nipple gently flexes during feeding sessions. Thus ensuring a natural latch and enabling the babies to have better control over the flow of milk. If you want an even slower flow, there is an extra slow flow nipple option available. 

The curvy shape of Tommee Tippee bottles offers a comfortable grasp for both babies and parents. Thus making feeding sessions more enjoyable. The wide width of the bottle and the minimal parts make cleaning a cinch. So, it reduces hassle and saves valuable time for busy parents. 

While Tommee Tippee bottles provide numerous benefits, it is important to consider a few drawbacks. These bottles are not dishwasher safe and require manual cleaning. A leak may occur if the nipple is not properly inserted or the flow is too fast. To avoid these issues, it is important to choose the appropriate size nipple for your baby’s needs. 

Feedback from Babylist parents reveals a positive response to Tommee Tippee bottles. Parents show their appreciation for their small and wife design, comfortable nipple, and overall ease of use. Parents also find the ability to hold the bottle in three different ways beneficial. It allows them to find the most convenient and supportive position for feeding their baby upright. 

Remember that while the baby is feeding, some liquid may get trapped in the bottle’s curves. So make sure to have proper nipple insertion into the lid to prevent any potential leakage. 

So, Tommee Tippee bottles are an excellent choice for parents looking for a bottle that mimics breastfeeding. But also wants a comfortable and natural feeding experience. Despite the need for manual cleaning and leakage concerns, Tommee Tippee bottles remain a good choice among parents. 

Comotomo Silicone Baby Bottle:

Easiest to Clean:


  • Material: Silicone
  • Available Sizes: 5 oz, 8 oz


  • Easy to clean
  • No special cleaning brush is required
  • Easy to latch
  • Soft and flexible


  • Occasional Leakage Problem
  • Volume markers are hard to see

Comotomo Silicone Baby Bottles have a design that closely resembles natural feeding and are easy to clean. Made from soft silicone, this bottle offers a natural and comfortable feeding experience for babies. 

Cleaning this bottle is a breeze due to its wide neck and minimal parts. Unlike some other bottles, no special cleaning brush is required. The simplicity of its design means there are only three parts to clean, making the process quick and hassle-free. The soft and flexible silicone body allows babies to easily latch onto the bottle, mimicking the experience of breastfeeding.

For self-feeding, optional handles can be attached when your baby is ready. It has a single hole to regulate the flow rate appropriately in newborns to three-month-olds.

However, there are a couple of downsides to consider. It’s important to ensure that the lid is tightly screwed on to prevent occasional leakage issues. Additionally, the soft base of the bottle makes it less stable and prone to tipping over. Another drawback is that the volume markers on the bottles are difficult to see. This makes it challenging to accurately gauge the amount of formula or milk inside. 

Experts recommend Comotomo bottles for their user-friendly cleaning features. These silicone bottles feature an extra-wide opening and only three pieces, eliminating the need for a brush. The built-in dual anti-colic vent helps prevent the intake of unwanted air, promoting a more comfortable feeding experience.

When filling the bottle, be aware that its flexible shape can cause it to tip over. Additionally, reading the volume measurements through the frosted silicone material can be challenging.

Parent feedback on Babylist says the wide bottle design makes cleaning easy, and the overall design is simple. Babies who prefer soft silicone bottles benefit most from the material.

The Comotomo Silicone Baby Bottle offers convenience with its easy-to-clean design and provides a breastfeeding-like experience for babies. It is not uncommon for Comotomo bottles to leak and the volume markers are hard to read. But parents who value simplicity and comfort continue to use them.

Philips Avent Anti-Colic Baby Bottles:

Best Bottle to Reduce Discomfort:


  • Material: Polypropylene
  • Available Sizes: 2 oz, 4 oz, 9 oz, 11 oz


  • Reduce colic and discomfort from gas
  • Easy to grasp
  • Easy to clean


  • Occasional Leakage Issues

Philips Avent Anti-Colic Baby Bottles are designed to address colic and discomfort caused by gas. These bottles are crafted to be easy to hold and feature specially structured nipples to prevent collapsing.

In terms of cleaning, Philips Avent Anti-Colic bottles are a breeze to maintain. With only four parts and a wide neck, they offer a hassle-free cleaning experience. The bottles are made from durable polypropylene material, ensuring their longevity and safety for your little one.

Although occasional leakage issues have been reported, these bottles still provide effective relief for colic symptoms. The reduced air intake design helps minimize discomfort and gas-related problems during feeding. 

Their user-friendly design makes them easy to grasp, allowing both parents and babies to handle them with ease.

Philips Avent Natural and Philips Avent Anti-Colic bottles offer more options in terms of size and nipple design. These models share the simplicity and leak-free qualities of the Anti-Colic bottles, with interchangeable parts for added convenience.

Some babies, especially younger ones, may have difficulty latching onto the Natural bottle due to its wider nipple. On the other hand, the Anti-Colic bottle features a narrower nipple that may appeal to certain infants.

Both the Philips Avent Natural and Philips Avent Anti-Colic bottles have gained popularity and high ratings among parents. They are also competitively priced, making them an affordable option for those seeking reliable and efficient feeding solutions.

In conclusion, the Philips Avent Anti-Colic Baby Bottles offer a practical solution for parents dealing with colicky babies. Designed to relieve colic and gas discomfort, these bottles are easy to use, easy to clean, and effective. 

Although occasional leakage has been reported, the overall benefits of these bottles make them a popular choice among parents. It can help you to stop having crying children and we know how much that can come in handy. 

How to Choose the Bottle for a Messy Eater?

Here are a few factors to consider when choosing a bottle for a messy eater. I always focus on having a slow-flow nipple and an anti-colic venting system. Apart from that, the bottle should have an easy latch and be made with BPA-free materials. Now, let us get into the details to know about each of these factors. 

Slow Flow Nipple:

When a baby has extra food in their mouth, they often pool out milk. Babies normally take time to swallow, and if they keep getting milk, it leads to a mess. This happens if the nipple has a fast flow. 

As a buyer, you need to check the nipple size separately. Normally, smaller hole sizes come with a slower flow rate and less probability of spilling out the milk. Check if the baby finishes the bottle in around 15 minutes. If it takes significantly less, you have a fast-flowing nipple. This is not just a concern while selecting a bottle but also a good  pacifier for a lip tie. 

Anti-Colic Venting System:

Anti-colic venting helps reduce air swallowed during feeds, reduce gas bubbles in the stomach, and slow down food intake. 

Air is drawn into the bottle through strategically placed vents, away from the milk. Following the principle of Fluid Dynamics to reduce milk velocity and increase the pressure. This means more comfortable meal time and less spilling out. 

Easy Latch:

Easy latch baby bottles feature a nipple design that has a comfortable and proper latch for babies. These nipples allow for sustainable latching during feeding. The collapse-resistant feature prevents any kind of mess. 

Easy latch bottles are also helpful to transition a baby from breastfeeding to bottle feeding. So, for an improved feeding experience, choose an easy latch option. Typically, it imitates the shape of a breast and has an easy latch advertised. 

Normally, latching is an important factor to consider. Just like a pacifier clip latching onto the soothie, you want the baby to properly latch onto the bottle. 

BPA- Free Materials:

In baby bottles, BPA-free materials are safer since they don’t contain potentially harmful chemicals. This is used to make certain plastics and resins. You can check this by looking at the product description. Normally, bottles are made from materials like borosilicate glass or stainless steel. 


Cleanability refers to how easy it is to clean the bottle. This means even if the baby makes a mess while having a meal, you can clean it. Normally, you can check the product description or look for a dedicated brush in the bottle. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

Can a Bottle with a Weighted Straw Help Reduce Mess During Feeding?

Yes, a bottle with a weighted straw can help reduce the mess during feeding. Since the star always points down regardless of the angle the baby is holding the cup which reduces spills. But it is a tiny factor and younger babies might not be comfortable having a bottle with weighted straw. 

What are Some Signs that a Bottle is Not Suitable for a Messy Eater? 

After milk comes out of the baby’s mouth, the burp cloth should be completely soaked. Other signs are milk pooling out from the baby’s mouth due to fast nipple flow. Baby squirts the milk from the side of the nipple is also a good sign. You also need to check for milk dribbling  out from the side of their mouth. 

Are There Any Bottles with Anti-Slip Features that Will Help the Messy Eater to Hold the Bottle Properly?

No, unfortunately, there are no anti-slip features to help the messy eater to hold the bottle properly. Normally, there are bottles with anti-slip features but those are for older babies or toddlers. 


In conclusion, when it comes to feeding a messy eater, finding the best bottle is crucial. With its innovative design and spill-proof features, the best bottle for messy eaters ensures a hassle-free mealtime experience. 

Say goodbye to the frustration of spills and say hello to easy feeding. Invest in the best bottle for messy eaters and get them to experience a mess-free meal every time.

Read also: Best Chromebook for Homeschool

Leave a Comment