Wifi vs Non Wifi Baby Monitor | 9 Crucial Factors Compared

Choosing the best baby monitor for your little one can be daunting, especially with the wide range of available options. As a parent, we want the best for our kids, making the decision-making process even more stressful. With different types of baby monitors such as audio-only, video-only, WiFi, non-WiFi, and others, it’s essential to do thorough research and careful consideration to find the perfect fit for your family’s specific needs and preferences.

One of the most critical factors to consider when selecting a baby monitor is the type of connection it uses. This is where the Wifi vs non wifi baby monitors debate comes in. While there’s no one-size-fits-all solution, understanding the differences between these two types of monitors can help you make an informed decision. So, let’s explore the pros and cons of WiFi vs non-WiFi baby monitors and see which one suits your family’s needs better.

Wifi vs Non Wifi – What is the difference?

When deciding between WiFi and non-WiFi baby monitors, it’s important to understand the basic differences and be aware of the perks and pitfalls of each option.

So, let’s first go through the quick overview, and we’ll be doing the head-to-head comparison later.

➡️ Non-WiFi baby monitors are generally considered to be more secure and reliable, as they use a direct connection between the transmitter and receiver. They are also often less expensive and have a longer battery life compared to WiFi monitors. However, they have a limited range and can only be used within the house or nearby areas.

On the other hand, 

➡️ WiFi baby monitors offer greater flexibility and convenience, as they allow parents to monitor their babies from anywhere in the world, as long as they have an internet connection. They also come with advanced features like two-way communication, remote camera control, and smartphone app integration. However, they are also more prone to privacy and security risks, and can be affected by internet connectivity issues.

Why does it matter?

Why does it matter whether you choose a WiFi or non-WiFi baby monitor? Well, it all boils down to safety and security. While WiFi monitors are undoubtedly more convenient, they also come with some risks. As with any connected device, a cyberattack or privacy breach is always possible. Plus, some parents worry about the potential health risks associated with WiFi signals. In contrast, non-WiFi monitors are considered more secure and pose fewer risks.

When I first bought a baby monitor for my daughter (she is now a preschooler), I thought a non-WiFi monitor would be the most secure choice. But as I spent most of my time at my 9-5 consultant job, I quickly realized that a non-WiFi device wouldn’t cut it. Despite having a caregiver and her grandmother on hand, I couldn’t relax without keeping an eye on her (it’s just a mom thing, you know?). That’s when I decided to switch to Nanit Pro (an intuitive WiFi baby monitor offering higher quality video, tracking, monitoring, and suggestions), and it was a game-changer. With the ability to watch my daughter’s every move and communicate with the caregiver at any time, I finally had peace of mind. However, I’m aware of privacy concerns with WiFi monitors, that they can be accessed and hacked (though not with this device or the latest models with advanced security protocols).

Ultimately, the decision to choose a WiFi or non-WiFi baby monitor is a personal one that depends on your needs and priorities. As a parent, you’ll need to consider factors such as convenience, security, and budget before deciding. But don’t worry about comparing the two too much – just choose the one that best fits your needs, and remember that you may need to compromise on some features no matter which option you choose.

Wifi vs Non Wifi baby monitors – Comparing the 9 crucial factors

1) Security and privacy

Your baby monitor’s security and privacy are among the most important factors to consider when choosing between WiFi and Non-WiFi options. Non-WiFi baby monitors use a direct connection between the transmitter and receiver, which means that a third party is less likely to intercept the signal. Additionally, they are not connected to the internet, so there is no risk of hacking or other security breaches.

On the other hand, WiFi baby monitors are more susceptible to security and privacy concerns, as they are connected to the internet and can be accessed remotely. This means there is a risk of the signal being intercepted by hackers or other unauthorized parties gaining access to the monitor. While many WiFi baby monitors offer advanced security features such as password protection and AES encryption, there is still a risk that they could be compromised.

To ensure the security and privacy of your baby monitor, it’s important to choose a reputable brand that uses advanced security features and protocols such as AES 256-bit encryption. Additionally, it’s a good idea to use a strong, unique password for your WiFi baby monitor, and to keep the firmware up to date with the latest security patches. 

And still, if you’re concerned about security and privacy, a Non-WiFi baby monitor may be a better option.

2) Reliability and signal range

Reliability and signal range are the second most crucial factors when choosing the best baby monitors. As I previously discussed, the problem with my Non-Wifi device was, I couldn’t monitor my baby’s activities when outside or at the workspace; that’s why shifting to the Wifi device was the game changer for me. 

Non-WiFi baby monitors typically use either analog or digital signals to transmit audio or video from the baby’s room to the parent unit. Analog signals are less secure and prone to interference, while digital signals are more reliable and secure. They usually have a range of up to 1000 feet, which is suitable for most households.

On the other hand, WiFi baby monitors use your home’s WiFi network to transmit the audio or video signals from the baby’s room to your smartphone, tablet, or computer doesn’t matter where you are. But I observed a bit of delay (average of 5-10s) depending on the weakness of the internet connection. However, some WiFi baby monitors use advanced technologies like FHSS or DECT to enhance the signal range and reliability. 

If you have a small or medium-sized house and want a simple and reliable monitor, a Non-WiFi baby monitor may be the way to go. A WiFi baby monitor may be better if you need more flexibility and want to monitor your baby from anywhere. Just remember to choose a brand that offers advanced security features and protocols and to keep your firmware up to date for the best protection.

3) Ease of use and convenience

Regarding your convenience, Non-WiFi monitors are generally easy to set up and use, as they typically have fewer features and functions than WiFi monitors. They are also less dependent on internet connectivity, so you don’t have to worry about connectivity issues or signal drops.

On the other hand, Wifi devices come with features such as smartphone app integration, two-way communication, and remote camera control, making it easier for you to keep an eye on your little one while you’re on the go. 

But initially, WiFi monitors can be more complex to set up and use for non-techies; however, a few minutes of a short lesson on YouTube will be enough for you to get started, and eventually, you’ll be all set.

That being said, Choosing a WiFi monitor with a user-friendly app and interface with strong and stable connectivity is important. But if you prefer a simple, easy-to-use monitor that doesn’t require an internet connection, then a Non-WiFi monitor might be the way to go.

4) Features and Functionality

When it comes to the features, both are unique on their own. But no doubt, Wifi monitors tend to have the upper hand. These monitors allow you to watch live feeds of your baby from your smartphone or tablet, eliminating the need to carry around an additional receiver. You can also control the camera’s angle and movement remotely. Some WiFi monitors offer advanced features like motion detection, temperature sensors, and two-way audio. Additionally, you can easily share access to the monitor with family members, and some models can even be integrated with virtual assistants.

However, if you’re a person who wants to use your phone and monitor your baby at the same time, a separate monitor is the best option I can recommend; additionally, non-WiFi monitors can offer a reliable and lag-free connection, long battery life, and their long-range capabilities benefit larger houses.

5) Battery life and power source

You’ll find people complaining about Wifi monitors sucking their phone’s battery, but it’s not the case. Consequently, Non-Wifi monitors, with their high power consumption and dependency on the battery, can get you in the drain.

Make sure to get the perfect battery or choose that one with long battery life (at least 8 hours) so that you don’t need to worry about the power running out every time.

6) Video and audio quality

Wifi baby monitors generally offer excellent video resolution, ranging from 1080p to up to 2k since they are integrated with an app on your smart devices, which typically have HD screens. However, non-wifi monitors are also catching up in this regard. While previous versions of non-wifi monitors may not have been as comparable, but the latest ones often use FHSS technology for signal transmission, enabling them to produce high-quality video and audio signals that are less likely to drop or lag. Moreover, updated graphics and HD monitors will allow you to clearly monitor your little one anytime.

Both types of monitors have their own unique selling points when it comes to video and audio. However, it is important to note that Wifi monitors may face 2-10 second transmission delays, but you will be able to see high-resolution video on your phone and enjoy clear two-way communication. On the other hand, non-wifi monitors typically have smaller screens (ranging from 2.4 to 5 inches) that may not offer the same level of resolution as your phone, but the video and audio quality will never be affected by signal disruptions, and everything you see on the screen will be in real-time.

Ultimately, the choice is yours!

7) Compatibility with other devices

WiFi baby monitors have a clear advantage over non-WiFi monitors. WiFi monitors can be connected to your smartphone, tablet, or computer, allowing you to keep an eye on your baby from anywhere at any time. This is especially useful if you’re a working parent or if you’re traveling and want to check in on your baby.

Non-WiFi baby monitors, on the other hand, typically only work with a dedicated receiver that comes with the monitor. While this receiver may be portable, it’s not as versatile as a smartphone or tablet. If you want to check in on your baby, you may need to have the receiver with you, which can be cumbersome.

That being said, some non-WiFi monitors offer compatibility with other devices, such as Bluetooth speakers or headphones, which can be useful for hearing your baby’s sounds without disturbing others in the room. Additionally, some newer non-WiFi monitors may be able to connect to your smartphone via an app or Bluetooth (though these options may be limited).

Overall, a WiFi baby monitor is the way to go if you want maximum compatibility and versatility. 

8) Health concerns related to signals

First, it’s important to note that both wifi and non-wifi baby monitors emit electromagnetic radiation, albeit at different frequencies. 

There are potential health concerns related to the signals emitted by baby monitors, particularly with wifi monitors that use radiofrequency (RF) radiation to transmit signals. Some studies suggest prolonged exposure to RF radiation may have negative health effects, especially in children whose brains are still developing.

Non-wifi monitors, on the other hand, typically use frequency-hopping spread spectrum (FHSS) technology, which emits lower levels of radiation and is generally considered safer.

However, it’s worth noting that baby monitors’ electromagnetic radiation levels are generally considered to be quite low. Both wifi and non-wifi baby monitors must comply with specific safety standards and regulations, which limit the amount of radiation they can emit.

9) Cost and budget

Regarding cost, non-wifi baby monitors are generally less expensive than wifi baby monitors. Non-wifi monitors can range from as low as $20 to $200, while wifi monitors can range from $50 to $300 or more.

The price disparity between wifi and non-wifi baby monitors can be attributed to the advanced technology required by wifi monitors, which includes app integration, cloud storage, and high-speed internet connectivity. These features require more processing power, larger storage capacities, and more sophisticated hardware, which can drive up the production costs and the final retail price of the device. In contrast, non-wifi monitors rely on traditional analog or digital transmission technologies, which are less complex and require less processing power and memory.

As a result, a non-wifi video monitor device tends to be more affordable if you’re looking for a cost-effective monitoring solution.

WiFi & non-WiFi baby monitors that I would recommend

As we have covered the nitty-gritty of Wifi vs non wifi baby monitors, here are my favorite picks for the wifi and non-wifii video baby monitor devices. This quick overview can help you make the right purchase.

Nanit (Wifi-Based Monitor) – It’s a comprehensive and innovative device that offers a range of features for tracking a baby’s health, wellness, and development. Its advanced camera and app can provide personalized insights and sleep coaching tips to help parents understand and improve their baby’s sleep routine. The breathing wear and smart sheets also provide unique ways to track a baby’s growth and monitor their movements. Overall, the Nanit monitor could be a great choice for parents who want a high-tech, all-in-one monitoring solution.

Eufy Spaceview (Non-Wifi Monitor) – When I was looking for the perfect Non-Wifi models out there, I got to know about the Eufy baby monitors, which are my best bet until today. If you want a good range of Non-Wifi monitors that can let you see your baby’s moves from any angle and in high resolution, go with it.

Summing Up

Choosing the right baby monitor can be daunting for new parents, especially when deciding whether to go for a wifi or non-wifi monitor. Both options have their own set of benefits and drawbacks, making the decision even more challenging. However, carefully considering factors such as signal strength, video and audio quality, compatibility with other devices, health concerns, and cost, you can make an informed decision and find the best baby monitor to suit your family’s needs. In this guide, we’ve compared wifi and non-wifi baby monitors on these key factors to help you make the best decision for your family.

Related Reads:

➡️ Best long range non wifi baby monitor
➡️ Best Vtech baby monitor
➡️ The best baby monitor for travel

FAQs